Most lawyers put out fires; but agentic AI is enabling a fundamental shift, from reactive legal services to proactive risk prevention. This transformation isn't coming, it's already here
Key points:
-
-
-
Reactive service is obsolete — The traditional model of waiting for client problems has reached its expiration date. Proactive, AI-powered monitoring creates entirely new categories of legal value.
-
Consolidation is coming — Within five years, the legal sector will bifurcate between firms embracing agentic AI transformation and those clinging to traditional models.
-
Early adopters set expectations — Firms that deploy AI agents as embedded legal monitoring systems will establish new client expectations that laggards will not be able to meet.
-
-
Welcome back to The AI Law Professor. Last month, I explored why asking the question “What if AGI?” represents essential strategic planning for lawyers. This month, I’m examining a transformation already underway: How AI-powered legal risk management systems can prevent problems rather than just solve them, and what this shift means for the lawyer-client relationship.
When every business decision becomes an opportunity for real-time legal insight, the total addressable market for legal services grows exponentially — and AI, especially agentic AI, is going to make this happen at warp speed. Yet, this client-facing and proactive revolution isn’t about replacing lawyers with machines. It’s about reimagining the lawyer-client relationship entirely, moving lawyers from being reactive problem-solvers to embedded strategic partners who prevent issues before they arise.
The end of reactive lawyering
Picture a senior partner at a prestigious law firm, circa 1995, dictating a memo while associates conduct research, mostly by carefully perusing large legal tomes, in the library. Fast forward to today: that partner now types their own emails, the library has become digital databases, and junior associates spend more time with search algorithms than with senior mentors. Yet for all this change, the fundamental model has remained static. Lawyers still react to problems after they arise, bill by the hour, and treat technology as a tool rather than a collaborative method.
We’re standing at the threshold of something fundamentally different. The emergence of agentic AI isn’t merely about making existing processes faster or cheaper. It’s about transforming law firms from reactive advisors into proactive business partners, embedded in the real-time operations of their clients.
Current adoption of agentic AI follows a predictable trajectory. Firms deploy it for high-volume, low-risk tasks, such as document sorting, initial contract reviews, and basic due diligence. However, limiting agentic AI to these mundane tasks is like using a Ferrari to deliver pizza.
The fundamental model has remained static. Lawyers still react to problems after they arise, bill by the hour, and treat technology as a tool rather than a collaborative method.
The real power emerges when we reconceptualize the lawyer-client relationship entirely. Instead of waiting for the phone to ring with the next legal crisis, imagine law firms with AI agents continuously monitoring client operations, analyzing contracts in real-time, flagging potential issues before they metastasize into lawsuits.
This shift from reactive to proactive legal service delivery represents a classic disruption pattern. It doesn’t just improve existing services, rather it creates entirely new categories of value.
The proactive revolution
Here’s a prediction that might ruffle some feathers: Within five years, we’ll witness massive consolidation in the legal sector. However, it won’t follow traditional patterns of big law firms absorbing smaller ones. Instead, we’ll see a bifurcation between those firms that embrace agentic transformation and those that cling to traditional models.
The firms that thrive will look radically different from today’s partnerships. They’ll employ machine learning experts alongside lawyers, and they’ll offer managed services that embed AI agents directly into client operations — and they’ll charge for value delivered rather than time spent. Think of them less like law firms and more like legal technology companies that happen to employ lawyers.
Meanwhile, firms that treat AI as just another tool, that continue billing by the hour while using AI to work faster, will find themselves in a death spiral. They’ll have missed the tipping point when incremental change becomes revolutionary transformation.
Of course, the most exciting possibility isn’t incremental improvement but the creation of entirely new categories of legal value. Imagine a firm that doesn’t wait for contracts to go sour but monitors them continuously, alerting clients to changing circumstances that might trigger renegotiation. Picture legal departments that can simulate the regulatory implications of business decisions before they’re made, running thousands of scenarios through AI agents trained on relevant case law.
The most exciting possibility isn’t incremental improvement but the creation of entirely new categories of legal value.
This proactive model transforms lawyers from fire fighters into strategic partners. It expands the total addressable market for legal services by orders of magnitude. Every business decision becomes an opportunity for legal insight, and every operational change gets real-time analysis. A law firm could offer legal monitoring as a service, with AI agents acting as an always-on legal nervous system for clients.
Once firms start down this path, they’ll find it difficult to reverse course. Early adopters will set new client expectations that laggards simply cannot meet. The competitive advantages will compound over time as firms accumulate data, refine their models, and deepen client integration.
The choice is stark but clear
After decades of building AI tools for legal practice, I’ve learned to distinguish between hype cycles and genuine paradigm shifts. Agentic AI represents the latter. It’s not about doing the same things faster or cheaper; rather, it’s about fundamentally reconsidering what legal services could become.
The firms that will dominate the next era are already experimenting, learning fast, and profiting faster. They’re building products that automate commodity work while developing new service models that were impossible before AI. They’re treating technology not as a threat but as an amplifier of human expertise.
The choice facing today’s legal professionals is clear: Embrace the agentic AI transformation and help shape how AI can change your legal practice, or resist and risk becoming casualties of technological disruption. The medieval guild system of legal apprenticeship has ended — and the age of human-AI collaboration has begun.
Those who recognize this shift, invest in understanding and deploying agentic AI strategically, and reimagine their business models and service offerings won’t just survive this transformation, they’ll thrive.
Indeed, they’ll thrive in ways that would seem like science fiction to that senior partner dictating memos in 1995.
The future of law isn’t about replacing lawyers with machines. It’s about lawyers and machines working together to deliver value that neither could achieve alone. And that future has already begun.
Well, that brings us to the end of 2025! I wish you and yours a very happy holidays, and I’m excited to see what 2026 brings us. The future looks bright!
